Mattress Plush vs Firm


Disclosure :Sleepwithcomfort is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Mattress firmness means the thickness of comfort and support layers and what you feel when lying down on a particular mattress. Plush and firm mattresses are on the two opposite poles of firmness scale. A firmer mattress has thick support layers and thin comfort layers while a plusher mattress features thick comfort layers and thin comfort layers.

Firmness is a subjective factor_it entirely depends upon a person’s sleeping style and body weight. The way a mattress feels to you completely defines the comfort and support.  Like size, price, mattress quality and durability, firmness of a mattress is also one of the important and basic factors which one should take into consideration while mattress shopping.

Many mattress shoppers due to inadequate knowledge often find it difficult to choose between mattress plush vs firm. They often feel difficulties in the way and sometimes make a decision, which they regret later. To. Protect our readers from such bad conditions we have compiled a mattress plush vs firm comparison guide for them. 

A Detailed Comparison Between mattress plush vs firm In 2023: 

There are a number of distinctions between mattress plush vs firm. These differences may make one mattress better for you than the other. To assist you effectively we have broken down the article on heads and subheads. Read on to explore the striking differences between mattress plush vs firm.

Read our article on Firm vs Medium Firm Mattress

What is a Plush Mattress?

Mattress Plush vs Firm

A plush mattress has a cushioning elegant feel and under minimal body weight they concede well. A plusher mattress has contouring, dense and thick comfort layers which provide cloud-like comfort.

The extra thick padding makes a plus a mattress a top choice for those who suffer from sharp pressure points. Especially side sleepers, who face pressure build up on hips and shoulders. 

Who Should Buy a Plush Mattress?

The following of sleepers are the excellent candidate for a plush mattress

Due to this reason, a plush mattress is often considered the best mattress for side sleepers because it provides enormous lumbar support resulting in no pressure buildup on shoulders and hips. This sharp pressure alleviation enables side sleepers to sleep safe and sound without body pains. 

These sleepers who are habituated to constant turning and tossing at night should undoubtedly go for a plush mattress. Moreover, those seniors who are suffering from joint and arthritis pains, should choose a plush mattress because a plush mattress completely cradles the sleepers whole body resulting in no joint and arthritis pain.

It is also an excellent choice for petite sleepers who need more comfort and less support. A petite sleeper often finds himself uncomfortable on a firm mattress, because a firm mattress leads to significant pressure points. As a plush mattress cushion well and respond quickly, effectively relieving pressure points resulting in comfortable sleep and energetic mornings.

Also read Twin Mattress vs Twin XL

  • Respond well
  • Excellent pressure alleviation
  • Deep contouring and cushioning
  • Suitable for many sleepers
  • Irritating for plus size sleepers
  • Stomach sleepers, should avoid using a  plush mattress

What is a Firm Mattress?

Mattress Plush vs Firm

A firm mattress is one that scores high on the firmness scale. A firm mattress contains high density as thick support layers while features thin comfort layers. Due to thick support, the sleeper will not not sink into the mattress core  properly and will sleep on an even surface. 

Must read Purple mattress vs Puffy lux

Who should Buy A firm mattress?

The following sleepers should buy a firm mattress for gigantic support and sound comfort

  • Heavy Sleepers
  • Back sleepers
  • Stomach sleepers

A firm mattress is best known for spinal alignment. Due to little give away, it keeps the sleeper spine in proper position leaving no chances for spinal strain and pain.

Sleepers who sleep on their back and stomach, should buy a firm mattress because a firm mattress excessively sinks their shoulders and hips, which throws the spine out of position. Due to pressure build up on heavy parts of the body, the sleeper will face muscle stiffness, lower back pain and hip pain. Thus it is concluded that the best mattress for stomach and side sleepers is medium or medium firm mattress.

Considering body weight is also one of the most important factors in mattress shopping. 

People who weigh more than  230 need a major pushback for comfortable and sound sleep. Plush mattresses provide very little pushback so it is recommended to buy a firm mattress, if you are a heavy sleeper. A firm mattress keeps sleepers’ bodies uplift and supported.

  • Provide even surface for sleeping
  • No backs and hip pain
  • Suitable for many type of sleepers
  • Sleeps cool
  • Petite sleepers find it uncomfortable
  • Comfort level is less than a medium firm mattress

Advantages Comparison Between Mattress Plush vs Firm:

Due to the differences between comforts and support layers they are inclined toward different advantages. Some of the notable and significant advantages of form and plush mattresses are as follows.

Plush Mattress:

Plush mattress less and thick comfort layers lead to different and unique properties which are missing in other types of mattresses. Some of the most notable advantages of plush mattress are as follows:

Unbelievable Comfort

Plush mattreses provide peak and unmatchable comfort. The cushioning and cloud like comfort is unbeatable that you will not find on other other mattress. These mattresses will hug you like a loving and caring mother and will provide the comfort that you ever dreamt off.

Physical Relief

Due to deep contouring and forgiving support plush mattresses are ideal for body sores and pains. It is suitable for aging populations who are more susceptible to joint pain, menopause pain, spinal atenoaid pain and sciatica pain.

Shape Conforming Support

Unlike, firm mattress, a plush mattress provides shape conforming support_ entirely hugs the whole body for deep contouring support. The base layers of a plush mattress are designed for providing support while the top comfort layers are intended for sothinga and cushioning support. They are specialized for providing comfort and support to the curve of the body. It is suitable for all body pains and aches.

Firm mattress:

The level of comfort and support which a particular mattress provides depends entirely on the mattress construction and quality materials used.

Lower lumbar Support

Stomach sleepers and plus size sleepers  will get rid of lower back and hip pain by using a firm mattress. Firm mattress is ergonomically designed to uplift the sleepers body and prevent excessive sinkage into the middle of the mattress. These properties keep the sleeper’s spine, hips and shoulders in proper alignment, resulting in a healthy and peaceful sleep experience. While sleeping on a firm mattress, may throw stomach and plus size sleepers out of alignment, leaving them irritating and painful nights and mornings.

You may also like to read: Medium firm VS Firm Mattress

Motion Isolation Restriction

Motion isolation restriction is of utmost importance for couples. Firm mattresses are known for excellent and significant motion isolation. According to the high density support layers prohibit the transfer of motion from one part of the mattress to the other part.

If your partner is habituated to constant turning and toss g, don’t worry as you are not prone to feel even a minimal disturbance. The motion isolating feature of a particular mattress is exclusively associated with the type of construction, the quality of materials used and the in which the mattress has been assembled.

Evenly Distribute Body Weight

A firm mattress provides an even surface for sleeping and prevents the sleeper from sinking into the core of the mattress. Due to no quicksand feel, they evenly distribute body weight resulting in reaction of pressure points. The sturdy support is really good for stomach sleepers and us size sleepers, who are prone to sharp pressure points when lying down on a plush or medium mattress.

Don’t Miss to read: Latex VS Foam Mattress

Durability Comparison Between Comparison Between Mattress Plush vs Firm:

The durability of mattresses are associated with the type of comfort employed and the quality of material used. Mattreses employing durable materials and sophisticated designs coat more then these mattresses that feature simple design and lower quality material. The durability has no concern with the fiemness of the mattress. So, both firm and plush mattresses can last for at least 7 to 10 tears if they are made of high quality material.

Buyer Guide 

IIt’s important that on the market no pure plush and firm mattress is available. The mattress which was between these two extreme poles can be purchased. These both mattresses have extreme proptettiss, which are not flexible to adjust with. You can buy medium firm, medium, or medium soft beds. Firmness is the primary indicator that the mattress will feel supportive and comfortable to a particular sleeper.  Firmness of a mattress is a non objective factor which entirely depends upon a person’s sleeping style and body weight. For every sleeper the comfortable firmness level varies.

  • Are you petite and sleep on your side? Are you suffering from joint discomfort and muscle strain? Are you a restless combination sleeper? Then you are surely searching for a plush size mattress that has deep contouring, responds well and provides a bit of the sinking feeling.
  • Are you the one who sleeps on the back, and stomach? Are you a plus size sleeper and want to sleep cool? Do you sleep with your partner? Then you are most probably searching for a firm mattress.

Choosing between a Mattress Plush vs Firm is a hectic job and then becomes difficult. Due to misleading content, one might wonder what is true and what is deceiving. To give rest to these conditions, equip yourself with certain basic knowledge about mattress construction and mattress function.

It will help you a lot through the way of mattress shopping. Some of the factors which should be in your pocket while doing mattress shopping are mattress size, price, durability, edge support motion isolation, ease of movement, shipping procedure (bed in a box or white glove delivery), warranty, free night trail, noise, and mattress type.

Other Factors To Consider:

Beside the above stated factors, two other main factors are construction material and Conner support. Different manufacturers uses different materials and zoned support to define the fitness of a mattress. For a better investment, there are few certain strategies, which are crucial in the way of mattress shopping.

  • How the brand has designed a particular mattress for optimization of comforts and support
  • What level and type of materials are being used employed to ensure durability, comfort and support of a mattress.
Construction Materials

let’s have a brief to top materials which are most frequently used in mattress construction, nowadays. 

Hybrid Mattresses

Hybrid mattresses are made made of wrapped coils and memory foam. It is the ideal choice for those sleepers who want a blend of plush and firm features. Hybrid mattresses also features different cooling materials do added cooling and comfort.

Inner Spring Mattresses

These are more affordable than hybrid mattresses and are known for their higher durability and breathability. These are more springy and boncy then any other type of material. The spring nature and sturdiness is directly proportional to the number and quality of materials used. It is best option for couples as it features excellent edge support.

Foam Mattreses

Foam was discovered by NASA in 1960 for protection of pilots during craft crash. The memory foam is made of polyurethane which is a synthetic polymer. Matteeses made of polyurethane are famous for deep contouring, significant pressure allaeviation and excellent motion. No mattress construction is completed without the use of mattress. Memory from mattress provide cloud like comfort which none other material can match.

Memory foam have the highest tendency to trap enormous quantity of heat which make a memory from mattre

Zoned Support

It’s a total myth that plush mattresses don’t provide support. Nowadays, zoning support is overcoming the less support level of a mattress. Beside providing comfort from one side of another, they also provide gigantic support from head to toes.

For example Casper mattress features 3 zoned system which provide targeted and zoned support to lumber, cervical, and thoracic region. Casper mattress provide a firm support to the lower back while provide varying degrees of firmness to shoulders and hips for pressure alleviation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a plush mattress good for couples?

No, a plush mattress is not good for couples because it contains less support layer which leads to the disruption of sleeper. They are not effective in motion isolation, so as your partner moves around, you will feel the movement at your side too. A medium and firm mattress are a good option for them as they have high potential to restrict the motion transfer.

Is a firm mattress cooler than a medium and medium firm mattress?

Yes, a firm mattress is cooler than a medium and medium firm mattress. Because A firm mattress does not tightly hug the sleeper body, leaving space for airflow which leads to dryer and cooler night sleep. On the other hand,  a medium firm and medium mattress tightly hugs the nappers body, leaving no spaces for air circulation resulting in sweat and hot night sleep.

Is a firm mattress good for a heavy sleeper?

Yes, a firm mattress is good for a heavy sleeper who weighs more than 230 pounds. Sue do high density and multiple support layers, a firm mattress has the capability to uplift the whole body of the sleeper. A firm mattress keeps the spine, hips and shoulders in spine alignment resulting in body pain and aches. If you are a plus size sleeper, never ever choose a plush mattress as it will lead to sharp pressure points.

What are the major categories of mattresses?

There are a total of 5 major categories of mattresses. These mattresses categories include memory foam, latex, hybrid innerspring and air bed.Memory foam and innerspring are the most affordable options, latex and airbed are luxurious and expensive while hybrid falls between these two opposite poles.

Final Verdict

Plush and firm mattress falls on the very ends of the firmness scale. These both types of mattresses are significantly different from one another in many aspects. Although a pure firm and plush mattresses are out of market, mattress manufacturers used the features of these two firmness options in mattress construction.

A particular type of fitness mattress depends upon personal preferences. preferences, body weight and sleeping style. Both firm and plush mattresses have targeted users who greatly enjoy sleeping on a firm and plush mattress. If you are suffering from any disease, it is highly recommended to consult your doctor before deciding between Mattress Plush vs Firm. The doctor will better guide you on which type of mattress is going to do great for you.

We have tried our level best in our Mattress Plush vs Firm, to eradicate all your confusion about firm and plush mattresses. Hopefully! this Mattress Plush vs Firm comparison guide will lead you to an ultimate decision.

Add comment

By Muhammad Asim